THYMUS EXTRACTS:
An International Literature Review of
Clinical Studies*
* © 1999 Foundation
for Immunology and Nutrition,
Development, Education and Research
Reviewed
by
James L. Wilson, Ph.D.
The past 20 years have witnessed
an explosive investigation of the immune system and the agents
governing it. One area of research involved the use of thymus
extracts. These extracts have proven surprisingly useful in
a wide variety of conditions, sometimes being the only effective
treatment (Skotnicki 89, Kouttab 89, Hadden 89).
OVERVIEW
A brief explanation of cellular and humoral
immunity
Although immunity
involves every organ and system of the
body, the typical conceptualization of
the immune system consists of
lymphocytes divided into two major
divisions: the humoral and cellular
aspects. Humoral immunity includes
primarily B lymphocytes and has to do
with antigen/antibody reactions. These
are the reactions involved in type I
(immediate hypersensitivity, IgE
response, anaphylaxis), type II
(hemolytic disease of the newborn, also
known as erthyroblastosis fetalis) and
type III (Arthrus) hypersensitivities.
In antigen/antibody reactions, B
lymphocytes secrete antibodies to an
antigen. An antigen is any substance,
typically a protein, that the body
recognizes as "non-self". The
antibodies attack an antigen by clumping
around it. Simultaneously they weaken it
and signal for other aspects of the
immune system (especially the complement
system and phagocytosis) to immobilize
and dispose of the antigen. No direct
contact of the B lymphocyte with the
antigen is necessary. Cellular immunity,
however, is medicated primarily by the T
lymphocytes and involves cell to cell
contact with microorganisms and other
pathogens. The T helpers, T suppressors,
T cytotoxic, killer (K) cells and
natural killer (NK) cells are part of
this system. Macrophages and monocytes
are also recruited by members of this
array of cells and are involved in
constant direct combat with the
pathogens and renegade cells that
constitute most of the chronic diseases
from which we suffer. The cellular
branch of immunity is, therefore,
responsible for vigilance against
neoplastic and aging cells, as well as
viruses, fungi (Odds 94), and some
bacterial (Berkow 87, p260) and
parasitic infections (Rothbard 90,
Gasbarre 82).
Maturation of T
lymphocytes
Histologically, T
lymphocytes mature in the thymus gland
but are a part of the myelopoietic cell
line and have their origin in the bone
marrow. As they develop, they carry
specific cell surface markers on the
periphery of each cell which are used to
identify each cell type. These cell
markers change as the cell matures.
Immature thymocytes in bone marrow carry
a CD1 (also known as T1) marker. Some of
them migrate to the thymus gland for
maturation beginning in the late part of
gestation. The rest continue to migrate
to the thymus throughout life with the
greatest migration taking place in the
first two years of life and at 13-16
years of age. As they mature and begin
to migrate out of the bone marrow,
thymocytes drop the CD1 marker and begin
carrying a CD3 lymphocyte cell surface
marker. When a CD3 (also known as T3)
cell I brought into contact with an
antigen appropriate for a cellular
immune response, the T cell matures by
committing to that particular antigen
and becomes a T helper/inducer cell and
hence adds a CD4 (also known as T4)
marker to its cell surface. Other T
cells become suppressor or cytotoxic
cells which carry CD8 (also known as T8)
markers. Once T cells are committed,
they remain vigilant and committed to
that antigen for life but depend upon
the presence of the thymic hormones for
normal activity (Berkow 87, p260-1).
Thymic hormones and
their down stream cell products (such as
interleukins and interferons) control
all phases of maturation, development,
antigen commitment, proliferation and
cytotoxic activity of the various T
cells. Thymic hormones also stimulate
non-specific phagocytic and cytotoxic
cells to respond against foreign or
"non-self" antigens.
Causes of compromised
immune function
It is hard to exist
and not pose some insult to the immune
system. Indeed, it is the combination of
what the body is exposed to and its
ability to respond that comprises the
adequacy of the immune response. In any
epidemic, only a portion of those
exposed become infected, only a portion
of the infected become ill, and only a
portion of those who become ill are
overcome and die. The difference in each
of these stages is the adequacy of the
response of the immune system. There are
many factors which have been shown to
affect immunity. Nutrient status has
been shown to be fundamental to a proper
immune response (Berkow 92, p317).
Inadequate nutrient intake results
specifically in T cell immunodeficiency
(Nezu 94, Wing 88); affects delayed-type
hypersensitivity (DTH) skin tests; and
reduces T cell numbers, proliferative
responses to mitogens, and cytotoxic
activity (Berkow 92, p318). In addition
to overall nutritional status and sub
optimal nutritional intake, the
following conditions also lend the body
to immunocompromised states: excess or
lack of exercise (Wiik 96, Boyum 96);
physical trauma (Wichmann 98),
especially involving head injuries
(Sacks 95, Meert 95, Quattrocchi 92) and
burns (Cairns 94); inadequate amounts
and quality of sleep (Born 97, Wiik 96,
Boyum 96, Irwin 96); excess fatigue (Bennet
98); starvation (Nezu 94, Wing 88);
smoking (McAllister 98); excessive
intake of alcohol (Faunce 97); most
recreational drugs including
barbiturates (Nagylucskay 92), cocaine (Stanulus
97, Watson 83, Di Francesco 90),
marijuana (Cabral 98, Klein 98, Tang 92,
Spector 90); and prescription drugs such
as steroids (Daynes 95, Berge 94) and
narcotics (DeWaal 98, Roy 96, Caar 95,
Rouveix 92, Novick 91); iatrogenically
induced stresses such as chemotherapy (Periti
87, Rosenthal 87, Rosenthal 88, ten
Berge 94), surgery (Samanci 98, Brivio
98, Zaporozhchenko98), radiation (Lieber
98, Tisch 98, Krutmann 98) and some
antibiotics (Fietta 83, High 92, Berge
94); extremes of weather (Komarov 85,
Stott 76, Kohnlein 73); aging (Hadden
89, Weksler 81); and chronic disease (Fiocchi
86, Cazzola 87, Tas 90). None of the
clinical trials reviewed in the
following text have attempted to control
for more than one of these variables.
These additional factors affecting
overall immune status will critically
influence the effectiveness of specific
immunotherapy in restoring an adequate
immune response.
Thymus Extracts
Composition of thymus
extracts
There has been some
confusion concerning the composition of
thymus extracts. In part this has arisen
because different products contain
varying amounts of three different
active hormones isolated from the
thymus: thymulin (also known as facteur
thymique serique or FTS(, thymopoietin
and thymosin alpha 1. Two other
partially purified active sybstances,
thymosin fraction V and thymostimulin
(TP-1), also contain constituents of
lymphocytes and epithelial cells in
addition to one of the thymic hormones (Hadden
89). The shortest active thymus fraction
producing demonstrable activity is an
oligopeptide (fraction V) with a
molecular weight of 3108 Daltons (Badamchian
97).
Other confusions have
arisen due to misleading literature from
some companies claiming that their
products are hormone free. Commercial
preparations, whether liquid or solid,
have typically contained at least one of
the three thymic hormones because
eliminating all of the thymic hormones
and other active fractions from the
stroma and parenchyma of thymus tissue
is a difficult procedure. To the author’s
knowledge, none of the commercial
preparations claiming to have eliminated
the hormone fractions filter out these
low weight molecules as it is a costly
procedure requiring special filters and
equipment and is difficult to achieve on
a commercial scale. Purification of one
or more of the active fractions,
however, has been done successfully on a
commercial basis for a number of years.
Most of the commercially available
thymus fractions are presently derived
from bovine thymus, except for thymulin
which is derived from porcine serum (Hadden
89). Virtually all of the literature
appearing in peer reviewed journals
involving the use of thymus extracts
have used liquid varieties. No studies
using powdered thymus extracts were seen
in reviewing papers published in the
last 25 years.
Biological properties
of liquid thymus extracts
Although there is
some evidence for improvement in B
lymphocyte function (Twomey 82), most of
the improvements seen using thymus
extracts have been within the cellular
branch of immunity involving T
lymphocytes (helper/inducer, suppressor,
cytotoxic, NK cells, K cells and
macrophages). Thymus extracts have been
shown to modulate the production,
maturation and activation of T
lymphocytes (Skotnicki 89, Kouttab 89,
Hadden 89) and macrophages (Andolina 87)
and to stimulate conversion of immature
thymocytes (T6 cells) to non-dedicated T
cells (T3 cells) in human bone marrow (Kouttab
89). In the more mature T cells, thymic
extracts have been shown to effectively
increase the number and function of T
helper/inducer lymphocytes (T4 cells) (Stankieweiz
86) and of suppressor cells (T8 cells) (Kouttab
89). Thymic extracts have also been
shown to enhance responsiveness to
concanavalin A (Con A) (Dabrowski 80)
and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) (Segatto
86), even in patients with
gastrointestinal tract malignancies
(Park 84) or in cells treated with
cyclophosphamide (Poli 86), a strong
immunosuppressor. These are important
findings as both PHA and Con A are major
in vitro tests for T cell mitogenesis
(proliferation) and increased cytotoxic
activity in T cytotoxic cells (Rosen
89). Lymphocytes in patients with
malignancies and those treated with
immunosuppressive drugs such as
cyclophophamide are typically
unresponsive to PHA or Con A. Thus,
thymus extracts have been able to
produce an immune response in laboratory
tests, even in significantly
immunocompromised patients who were
previously unresponsive (Cangemi 93,
Fagiolo 93).
In addition to
laboratory tests for immune competence,
clinical tests for cellular immunity are
sometimes employed. The most common is
the delayed-type hyper-sensitivity (DTH)
skin test. Small amounts of test
antigens such as candida, streptokinase/streptodornase
(Sk/Sd), tetanus toxoid (Berkow 92,
p308), mumps, and trichophyton antigens
(Berkow 87, p279) are injected
subdermally. These antigens normally
produce a raised and indurated skin
wheal several millimeters in diameter,
24-48 hours after injection. A lack of
reaction to this group of antigens
indicates a lack of immunocompetence of
the cellular immune response. Thymus
extracts have been shown to regenerate
and/or increase the production and
activity of T lymphocytes and
macrophages and/or to effectively
restore skin test responsiveness in
previously unresponsive patients (Lasisz
90, Periti 93).
Extracts of thymus
glands from bovine, ovine or porcine
sources have been available for more
than 65 years (Harrower 32). Most of the
basic and clinical research has been
conducted over the last 15 years in
Russia, Poland, Italy, Spain, German and
Switzerland. There are several different
liquid thymus products appearing in the
literature. Overall, the results using
these liquid preparations are
encouraging, demonstrating an
effectiveness of thymic fractions
whether administered by injection or
taken orally (Kouttab 89).
Clinical Applications
of Thymus Extracts
As mentioned above,
the cellular branch of immunity is
responsible for vigilance against
chronic viruses, fungi, yeast, and
parasitic infections as well as
neoplasms and aging. Thymus extracts
have been used clinically in a variety
of ways involving some of these
conditions. They have been used orally
and as injectables; by themselves and in
combination with other therapeutics.
Thymus extracts have been used to treat
severe and chronic allergies involving
the respiratory tract and skin as well
as in severe acute and chronic
infectious diseases. The extracts have
also been shown to reduce post surgical
infections, decrease the damage of
chemotherapy and radiation and have been
used as adjuncts to mainstream therapy
for treatment of neoplasms. The review
of literature presented below is a
survey of the conditions treated using
thymus extracts and demonstrates the
research completed to date using thymus
extracts.
Infections
The effector
mechanisms involved in the immune
response against infectious agents are
mainly macrophages, natural killer (NK)
cells, granulocytes, and T and B
lymphocytes (Kouttab 89). Clinical
improvement depends heavily upon the
number and competence of these cells.
Hence, cellular immunity is a key to
proper recovery from infective states.
Respiratory ailments
Recurrent respiratory
infections (RRI) in children
Double blind studies
revealed that thymomodulin, a thymus
extract, given orally to children was
able to reduce the number of RRIs
compared to placebo controls and to
previous year infections in the same
child. An increase in CD3 and CD4 cells,
neutrophil functions and salivary IgA
levels was also seen (Fiocchi 86). The
same extract was also successfully used
prophylactically in children with RRI.
Continued use prevented relapses of
infections and produced an increase in
phagocytic responses of alveolar
macrophages and serum immunoglobulins (Kouttab
89).
Another calf thymus
extract, TFX, was compared to levamisole
(Ergamisol), a pharmaceutical
immunomodulator, in a placebo controlled
trial to treat children suffering from
chronic bronchitis. The children chosen
for the study had a minimum of 9 months
of recurring bronchitis with at least 1
episode per 2 months and were from 19
months to 10 years of age. Both of the
treatment groups (TFX and levamisole)
showed statistically significant
decreases in the number, severity and
duration of episodes, and each group
required less antibiotic therapy. There
was also a tendency toward normalization
of the number and function of T
lymphocytes in both groups (Skotnicki
89, Radomska 87).
Adult bronchitis
Improvement was also
seen in 20 of 26 adults with recurrent
upper respiratory tract infections
(URI). All subjects were experiencing 8
to 10 severe episodes/year and were
resistant to antibiotics, vaccinations,
inhalations and other treatments. Each
received the thymus extract, TFX, orally
daily for 1 month and every second day
thereafter for 12 months. Quantitative
and/or functional improvements in T
lymphocytes were seen in 70% of the
patients. These improvement corresponded
with clinical improvement manifested by
decreased number and severity of
episodes, and decreased or no need for
antibiotics. One year after treatment
was discontinued, patients still
reported an improved status. The
physician’s conclusion was that thymus
extract was "the treatment of
choice" as it effectively changed
the natural course of the disease by
working at the causative level; i.e. the
faulty immune process, rather than at
the combative (antibiotics) or
symptomatic (bronchodilators, etc.)
levels (Stankiewiez 86).
Chronic spastic
bronchitis
Treatment with TFX
thymic extract injections 2x/week for
one year used in conjunction with
Encortolone [prednisolone (Arizona 93)]
(4-12 mg/day) produced clinical
improvement and normalization of the
granulocyte phagocytic index, but did
not alter the defective response in
granulocyte migration tests (MIF) (Matusiewicz
87). The author attributed the lack of
change to the immunosuppressive effect
of the steroid. Similar results were
found in other studies (Gieldanowski 81,
Smogorzewski 84) confirming that thymus
extracts can yield a greater clinical
benefit in pulmonary infections than
steroids by themselves. Although
response is greater and complications
fewer, lasting improvement should not be
expected when used in conjunction with
immunosuppressive steroids.
Bronchial asthma in
patients with atopic determatitis
One-hundred-and-sixty-three
patients treated for bronchial asthma
with the thymus extract, vilozen, showed
improvement in clinical signs and
symptoms as well as T cell activity. The
substance was said by the author to
correct the immune disorder (Kogosova
90). Orally administered thymomodulin
improved clinical symptoms and reduced
the frequency of acute allergic episodes
as well as decreased IgE titers and
eosinophil counts (Kouttab 89, Fiocchi
87) in patients suffering from combined
bronchial asthma and atopic determatitis
(Bagnato 89).
Thymus extracts have
also been used with patients suffering
from combined bronchial asthma and
atopic dermatitis to help counterbalance
the unfavorable environmental effects of
living in polluted air caused by a large
industrial power plant. The treatment
helped raise immune responsiveness of
these patients and significantly
increased treatment efficacy of
bronchial dilators (Gregor’ev 89).
Chronic Respiratory
Infections
Angina &
bronchitis
Eighty-six patients
with angina and concomitant bronchitis
received antibiotics, splenin (a spleen
extract) and vilozen (a thymus extract)
in a clinical trial. They were compared
to 52 controls who received routine
treatment. [Routine treatment for angina
is typically nitroglycerin under the
tongue upon attack. Treatment for
bronchitis is rest, fluids and
antipyretic and/or analgesic drugs (Berkow
92, p 504 & 658 respectively)]. The
results revealed that a combination of
splenin and vilozen produced a
pronounced fortification of the immune
response in the treated group,
consequently improving their clinical
status. The authors recommend that
immunomodulators (thymus and spleen
extracts) are indicated in the treatment
of repeat and relapsing angina,
especially in the presence of
comcomitant bronchitis (Frolov 92).
Chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease (COPD)
COPD is the
combination of chronic obstructive
bronchitis and emphysema (Berkow 92,
p358). The imbalance of phagocyte
functions in COPD include a reduction in
PMNs (polymorphonuclear leukocytes) and
monocyte chemotaxis and a decreased
killing capacity due primarily to a
reduced myloperoxide capacity of these
cells.
A prospective
randomized trial was completed on 78
patients with COPD. Thirty-eight
patients were given the thymus extract,
thymostimulin (TP-1), intramuscularly
(1mg/kg/day) for the first week followed
by once per week for 6 months, in
addition to the standard treatment for
COPD. Patients receiving thymostimulin
showed statistically fewer exacerbations
and hospital visits during the one year
follow-up period compared to the 40
controls receiving standard treatment
only. However, there was no change in
the number of patients with severe or
moderate impairment of respiratory
function. Also, there were no changes in
serum immunoglobulin or T cell subsets (Banos
97).
In another study,
patients suffering from COPD were given
thymostimulin (TP-1) for one year and
assessed during and after the trial
period. The results showed a return to
normal of myloperoxide capacity.
Phagocyte functional capacities,
however, were unaffected. A significant
improvement of clinical status was also
seen during the one-year program.
Because of the laboratory and clinical
improvement seen, the authors suggest
that thymostimulin be considered in the
treatment of COPD (Tortorella 92).
Diseases and
Infections of Viral Origin
Tuberculosis
Thirty older patients
with active tuberculosis were given the
thymus extract t-activin (tactivin) as
part of a multimodal therapeutic
regimen. The results showed an elevation
of T helper cells, enhancement of
lymphocyte activity and increased IL-2
synthesis. Enhancement of natural killer
cell activity and IL-1 synthesis by
macrophages were also observed. This
normalization of specific and
nonspecific immune responsiveness
paralleled clinical improvement (Adambekov
98).
The same thymus
extract appeared to benefit a group of
patients suffering from pulmonary
tuberculosis and type 1 diabetes
mellitus combined. Overall, patients
with these combined illnesses indirectly
showed more depression of cellular
immunity, as indicated by a decrease in
the number of T-lymphocytes and
decreased blast-cell transformation,
than those with tuberculosis alone. When
t-activin was added to the drug therapy
regime, immune parameters normalized.
The author also noted a more rapid
recovery and more frequent incidence of
recovery from tuberculosis in the
treated group. They suggested t-activin
be added to the therapeutic regimen of
patients suffering from type I diabetes
and tuberculosis. The authors also noted
a more frequent and rapid recovery from
tuberculosis in the treated group. As a
result of the study, they suggested
considering the addition of
immunomodulators such as t-activin as
part of the therapeutic regimen in type
I diabetic patients with tuberculosis (Karachunski
97).
Herpes simplex (HSV)
Herpes simplex is a
virus belonging to the herpesvirus
group. Herpes simplex type 1 (herpes
labialis, cold sores or fever blisters)
is transmitted primarily via oral or
respiratory routes. Herpes simplex type
2 (herpes genitalia) is transmitted
primarily by sexual contact (Tortora 86,
p536-7). The virus remains dormant in
the skin or nerve ganglia until
triggered by over exposure to sunlight,
physical or emotional stress, or certain
foods or drugs (Berkow 87). If immunity
is not established early in the course
of the disease, infection is usually
lifelong. The thymus extract, TFX, was
used to successfully treat 8 patients
suffering from recurrent herpes simplex
labialis. Patients received the extract
every second day for the first month,
then twice weekly for 12 months. No
reoccurrences were seen during the 12
months in 3 patients who had previously
averaged 5 to 10 outbreaks per year.
Clinical improvement was noted in 5
others. Frequency, duration and severity
of reoccurrence were all substantially
reduced while taking the extract.
Cessation of the treatment, however, was
associated with a return to the previous
characteristics of the illness (Skotnicki
89).
Herpes zoster
Herpes zoster is
another herpes-type virus that causes
chicken pox and shingles (Tortora 86,
p534). Although usually a self-limiting
viral disease, herpes zoster was used as
a clinical model to study the effects of
thymus extracts in 28 otherwise non-immuno-compromised
patients. Results of this double blind
trial reported an accelerated rate of
wound healing, shorter duration of
vesicles, shorter time to first and full
crusting lesions, as well as a greater
amelioration of pain during the acute
phase (Skotnicki 89). Thus, thymic
extracts were shown to be effective in
treating viral infections in non-immuno-compromised
subjects. This was further underscored
in a study treating 5 cases of recurrent
human papilloma virus (HPV) where each
patient received thymostimulin therapy
IM for 9 months. The results showed a
reduction in size and number of lesions
(Grismondi 91). Note that this is a
disease not thought to result from a
deficient immune function, yet treatment
with thymus extract was beneficial.
Acute and chronic
hepatitis B
Hepatitis B is caused
by the hepatitis B virus (HBV) and is
associated with a wide spectrum of liver
diseases, including a subclinical
carrier state, acute hepatitis, chronic
hepatitis, cirrhosis and hepatocellular
carcinoma. Chronic Hepatitis B occurs in
5-10% of patients who initially
contracted acute hepatitis B infections
(Berkow 92, p902).
Acute hepatitis B:
Significant decreases were seen in total
bilrubin and iron levels in conjunction
with more rapid clinical improvement and
shorter hospitalization time in a group
of 15 patients with laboratory confirmed
acute hepatitis. Patients were given 15
injections of the thymus extract, TFX,
beginning the day of diagnosis and
followed over the course of the disease
until recovery (Kicka 86).
Chronic hepatitis B:
Chronic hepatitis B is a difficult
disease to treat and has a varying
prognosis. Only about 1/3 of the cases
develop from acute hepatitis. Most
develop insidiously de novo (Berkow 92,
p905). The disease has varying courses.
"Mild persistent hepatitis, full
blown chronic active hepatitis with
eventual cirrhosis, and a sub-clinical
chronic carrier state all occur. The
latter is especially prone to lead
ultimately to hepato-cellular
carcinoma" (Berkow 92, p903).
Illnesses associated with HBV tend to
progress and are usually relatively
resistant to therapy (Berkow 92, p906).
With present medical therapy, patients
usually live several years, but
hepatocellular failure, cirrhosis, or
both eventually develop in many cases (Berkow
92, p906).
The liver injury in
HBV is due to an immune mediated host
reaction to the infection and not the
infection per se (Berkow 92, p905). The
use of thymus extracts to normalize the
aberrant immune responses seen in
hepatitis B is a logical treatment
choice.
Consistent with this
line of reasoning, 18 patients with
biopsy proven chronic active hepatitis B
and a lowered T4/T8 ratio received
thymic extract TFX for 6 and 12 months
in two different groups (Dworniak 91).
Improvement in the T4/T8 ratio was seen
beginning 14 days after treatment had
begun, followed by a decrease in the
abnormally high NK cell count. As the NK
cell count decreased, NK cell migration
and killing activity increased to normal
in both the 6 and 12 month groups.
Normalization of biochemical and
immunological parameters occurred within
5-6 months of beginning treatment.
Seroconversion of HBe system to antiHBe
was observed after 9-12 months in both
of the treatment groups. HBe is a blood
marker for presence of the virus core.
It indicates active viral replication.
Seroconversion to anti-HBe (the antibody
to HBe) indicates the virus has ceased
replication. This seroconversion usually
portends a benign outcome (Berkow 92,
p906). A two year follow up showed
continued clinical remission with normal
immunological and biochemical panels in
both groups. The authors conclude that
the thymus extract had an
immunostimulatory action of lasting
duration. A similar study using TFX for
6 months on 29 patients produced similar
findings with similar conclusions (Zeman
91).
In another study,
thymomodulin thymus extract was
administered orally as a syrup at a dose
of 120 mg/day for 1 year to a group of
children with chronic hepatitis B who
had a positive HBs Ag and HBe b Ag blood
profile. The results showed a higher
rate of recovery and seroconversion to
anti-HBe than controls (Bortolotti 88,
Raymond 98).
Other liver diseases
including chronic cholestatic
hepatitis and primary biliary
cirrhosis have been successfully
treated by the thymus extract, t-activin.
Results of a study using 102 patients
with chronic cholestatic hepatitis and
primary biliary cirrhosis showed an
increase in T lymphocytes, increased
functional activity of mononuclear cells
(increased chemotaxis and inhibition),
and decreased immunoglobulin counts. All
of these indicators signify an increased
immune competence which favors
controlling the immuno-inflammatory
process in the liver and a normalization
of the clinical manifestation of the
disease leading to a favorable outcome (Radchenko
92). These results are important not
only for the successful treatment of a
very difficult disease which frequently
has an unfavorable outcome, but also for
the implications for treatment of
hepatitis produced by other causes. Many
of the inflammatory conditions of the
liver are caused by viruses, fungi, or
mycobacteria (tuberculosis) (Berkow 92,
p898). Cellular immunity is the chief
defense against these agents. Successful
treatment of the above conditions using
thymus extracts suggests many exciting
possibilities for treatment of presently
untreatable ailments of the liver using
immunomodulating substances such as
thymus extracts.
Recurrent aphthous
stomatitis (RAS)
In a small clinical
trial, 5 patients suffering from
recurrent aphthous stomatitis for
periods ranging from 2 to 8 years
entered a 2 year trial using the thymus
extract, TFX. An overall beneficial
effect was seen in 4 out of 5 patients
as shown by decreased pain, frequency
and duration of lesions in 2 patients
and a complete disappearance of lesions
in 2 others. Discontinuance of
treatment, however, brought about the
return to the pre-treatment condition
for all patients within 12 months after
cessation (Skotnicki 84). As no drugs
are known to be effective in treating
RAS, its successful treatment using
thymus extracts should be considered a
therapeutic breakthrough. Even though
the results were not long lasting, the
therapeutic regimen was effective as
long as treatment was continued.
Dysentery due to
Shigella infection
Chronic and lingering
dysentery due to Shigella infection was
successfully treated in 51 patients
using the thymus extract, t-activin (Guliamov
91). In their discussion, the authors
emphasized that the cause of chronic
dysentery was a functional defect in the
lymphoid and phagocytic cells of the
colonic mucosa with an analogous defect
in the peripheral leukocytes. The
administration of thymus extract not
only eradicated the pathogenic
organisms, it also corrected the
functional defects in the lymphoid and
phagocytic cells, reduced inflammation
and ameliorated repair of the intestinal
mucosa.
Acute Inflammation of
the maxillofacial areas
One study reported
improvement in hypo/hyper-inflammatory
reaction using local subcutaneous and
endolymphatic injections of t-activin
with patients suffering from acute
inflammation of the maxillofacial area.
Overall improvement of patient status
and an arrest of inflammatory processes
was reported using this technique (Drobyshev
96). Another study using T-activin with
46 patients affected with acute
inflammatory disease of the
maxillofacial area also showed
improvement of depressed immune function
(Bazhanov 96).
Immunodeficiency
Diseases
Combined
Immunodeficiency
This is a group of
disorders characterized by congenital
and often hereditary deficiency of both
B and T cell systems, lymphoid aplasia,
and thymic dysplasia. This is a disease
typically manifesting within the first
three months of age with pneumonia,
thrush and diarrhea. Treatment is
usually with immunoglobulins and
antibiotics initially, followed by bone
marrow transplant. The untreated course
is usually fatal before the age of two (Berkow
92, p315).
Using the thymus
extract, TP-1, some improvement was seen
in 4 children with this disease (Davies
82). Total reconstitution of immunity
was not achieved and multiple drug
regimens were needed to sustain life in
these children, with 1 child succumbing
to complications of bone grafting. Two
of the 4 children, however, did show
marked improvement of immune function.
Monthly injections were needed to
sustain the children as a decline in
immunity was seen if the thymus extract
was withdrawn.
AIDS
The most extreme
example of viral infection of
lymphocytes with resultant immuno-suppression
is acquired immunodeficiency disease
(AIDS). The HIV virus is a retrovirus
which causes the destruction of T
helper/inducer (T4, CD4) cells. Several
studies using various liquid thymus
extracts have appeared with mixed
results in peer reviewed journals.
Although the lack of good experimental
design and protocol makes these studies
difficult to evaluate, some important
findings have emerged.
In one of the best
designed studies, 15 ARC and AIDS
patients were treated with liquid thymus
extract orally (Valesini 87). The
results showed significant increases in
T cells, T helpers and in T4/T8 ratios.
These indices play an important role in
the pathogenesis of AIDS (Berkesi 85).
Clinically, the number of patients
demonstrating chronic lymphade-nopathy
decreased by 2/3rds, fevers disappeared
in all subjects and the incidence of
thrush decreased remarkably during and
after treatment. One patient in the
study had been diagnosed with Kaposi’s
sarcoma (KS). This patient was in
complete remission when the study was
submitted for publication, several
months after treatment had ended. None
of the patients with ARC progressed to
AIDS during the study. These results
helped to confirm those of an earlier
study in which 3 subjects [one with AIDS
and two with lymphadenopathy syndrome
(LAS)] were responsive to treatment with
the same thymic extract (Valesini 86).
In another study
involving 34 subjects with ARC who
received injections of a thymus extract
2 times weekly for 6 months, significant
increases in leukocyte and lymphocyte
counts, as well as a significant
difference between control and treatment
group T4 counts were seen after 12
months (Pailisano 88). Delayed-type
hypersensitivity (DTH) skin tests, the
standard clinical tests for competence
of cellular immunity, also improved
significantly along with the
amelioration of other clinical indices
such as weight loss, fever, night sweats
and lymphadenopathy. Eighteen months
after the treatment had begun, none of
the 34 in the treatment group had
progressed to developing AIDS, whereas 3
of the 24 in the control group had
developed the disease. A similar study
had similar findings including the
difference between groups in their
progression from ARC to AIDS (Carco 84).
Twelve patients in the early stages of
HIV infection were treated with the
thymus extract, thymomodulin. 60 mg
orally/day for 50 days. A normalization
of the T4/T8 ratios with an increase in
T4 cell numbers was reported along with
improvement in the clinical course of
the disease (Valesini 87).
Other researchers,
however, found no difference in the
clinical course of the disease or
survival time using injections of the
thymus extract, thymostimulin (TP-1) at
1mg/kg per day for 14 days, followed by
weekly injections for 12 weeks (Chacoua
89, Beall 90). The differences in
outcome may have been an effect of the
stage of the disease at which therapy
was instigated, since both of the
authors reporting no difference in the
clinical outcome used subjects with more
advanced cases. As AIDS cases advance,
the T helper cells become severely
decreased (Berkow 92, p83). One of the
prime targets of thymic extracts appears
to be the T helper cell. Decreased cell
populations would, therefore, be
consistent with decreased
responsiveness.
The overall
implication of these studies is that
thymus extracts may be effective in
stabilizing or sometimes reversing
laboratory and clinical manifestations
of ARC and AIDS. The activity appears to
be focused directly on the T cell
lineage from pre T lymphocytes to mature
T cells (Weksler 81). Although there
were some concerns that this might
indeed provide more T cells to be
infected, no study has supported this.
Allergies
Perennial allergic
rhinitis, bronchial asthma and atopic
dermatitis are all known to result
primarily from a defect in cellular
immunity. All have shown benefit from
using an oral administration of thymus
extracts (Kouttab 89, Genova 86, Fiocchi
87). In one study, 18 patients with
chronic purulent rhinosinusitis were
treated with TP-1 thymus extract
administered daily by intramuscular
injection for 14 days followed by 2
injections/week for 6 weeks further. All
patients had demonstrable defects in
their cell-mediated immune system before
treatment had begun. All 18 patients
showed clinical improvement. Twelve out
of 15 reported feeling better during
TP-1 therapy. Thirteen patients showed
an absence of mucopurulent secretion in
the nasal mucosa. Positive bacterial
culture rates from nasal mucosa
decreased by 2/3rds from 14 out of 15
subjects to 5 of 15. The clinical
improvements were accompanied by an
increased performance of functions of
the cell-mediated immune system, the
most significant of which was increased
monocyte activity (Tas 90). Placebo
treatment had no significant effect.
Skin Diseases
Atopic eczema
Beneficial results
using thymus extracts have also been
obtained with children suffering from
atopic dermatitis (also known as atopic
eczema and AD). One characteristic of
this disease is a nightly occurrence of
intractable itching which causes
uncontrollable scratching of lesions.
The itch-scratch-irritated rash cycle
due to the circadian elevation of IgE
and consequent mast cell release of
histamine at the lesion sites is a
significant part of the symptom picture.
Poor wound healing and consequent
infection and reinfection from
scratching disrupted lesions is common.
Atopic children and adults also
frequently suffer from food allergies
caused by the hyper IgE response
patterns. The source of this disease is
thought to be a defect in T cells via
indirect regulation of IgE responses (Berkow
92). This is a problem seen daily in
dermatology clinics and is associated
with other immune defects such as hay
fever, rhinitis and bronchial asthma.
Twenty atopic
children were given the thymus extract,
thymodulin, 3mg/kg/day for 30 days. A
disappearance of the circadian
variability of serum IgE and hence the
nightly itch-scratch cycle was seen in
the children under treatment, whereas no
improvement was seen in controls (Pecora
91).
A clinical trial
using the elimination-provocation
dietary regimen was instituted with 20
atopic children, 10 of which received
the thymus extract, thymodulin, during
the elimination phase and 9 of which
were only withdrawn from food they had
previously shown sensitivity to. After
90 days the offending foods were
reintroduced. Skin lesions worsened and
IgE levels increased in controls, but no
increase was seen in either the skin
lesions or IgE levels (specific or
nonspecific) in the groups receiving the
thymus extract. IgE levels actually
decreased during the treatment phase for
the groups receiving the thymus extract.
The authors concluded that thymus
extract was useful in modulating IgE
disregulation in atopic children (Cavagni
89). Other studies have shown a general
improvement in the overall condtion of
atopic children receiving thymus
extracts (Kouttab 89, Kaliuzhnaia 90).
Only one study failed to find any
significant changes in either clinical
or laboratory results (Harper 91).
Psoriasis
Psoriasis is a
disease affecting 2-4% of the white
population. Lesions vary from 1-2
lesions to widespread dermatosis: from
disabling arthritis or exfoliation to
guttate-rash in the throat (Berkow 92,
p2435). Treatment varies from topical
applications of substances such as coal
tar and creams to systemic use of
corticoid steroids or even the cancer
drug, Methotrexate (Berkow 92, p2435).
A group of 74
patients with varying severity of
psoriasis (46% were classified as
severe) was treated with TFX injections
3x/week for one month followed by twice
weekly injections for 1-2 years. Results
showed that 76.4% of the participants
had remission of their lesions. Of the
patients suffering from severe
psoriasis, 33% showed an excellent
response and 36% showed a good response.
Ten of the 74 cases had long lasting
remission after discontinuing the drug
for more than 2 years. During the
treatment period, a decreased
sensitivity to viral and bacterial
infections and an improvement in general
clinical state and well-being was also
reported (Skotnicki 89).
Autoimmune Diseases
Rheumatoid arthritis
Rheumatoid arthritis
is a crippling and debilitating joint
disease affecting approximately 1% of
the North American population. Its
etiology is suspected to involve
autoimmune mechanisms (Berkow 92,
p1305). Several studies have shown the
effectiveness of thymus extracts in
treating this disease.
TFX thymus extract
was used in a trial in which 20 subjects
received daily injections for 3 months.
Eighty percent of those involved showed
clinical improvement as evidenced by
decreased joint swelling and tenderness
and an increase in muscle strength.
Forty percent showed a decrease in
rheumatoid factor alpha 2 and serum IgG
levels as well as an increase in
hemoglobin and serum iron levels (Skotnicki
86). Similar results were obtained in
two other studies (Skotnicki 89, Lasisz
90). It was concluded in these papers
that TFX was of therapeutic value in the
management of RA patients either alone
or in combination with anti-inflammatory
or basic anti-rheumatic drugs. A
separate review paper supported these
findings (Skotnicki 84).
In another study,
monotherapy with methotrexate (MT) was
compared with combined therapy with MT
plus t-activin thymus extract in a 2
year clinical trial involving 127
patients with RA. MT was given to 88
patients in a weekly dose of 7.5 mg. In
39 patients this dose was given in
combination with injections of t-activin
(100 mcg) twice a week for the first
month and once a week for the remaining
2 years. In both groups there was a
significant reduction in severity of
arthalgia, number of joints with
inflammation, severity of pain,
C-reactive protein levels and
erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR). In
the combined therapy group there was
also a reduction in morning stiffness
and join pain on palpation. The addition
of t-activin did not significantly
change the side effects of Methotrexate
(Oliunin 96).
Systemic lupus
erythematosus (SLE)
The efficacy of the
thymus extract, t-activin, on cellular
immune status of 49 chilcren, ages 8-15
suffering from SLE was examined.
Treatment with t-activin for 4 weeks
resulted in overall improved health
status and a reduction of SLE activity.
A rise in serum thymic factor and
increased T-lymphocyte differentiation
was also seen. In patients with
secondary infections, an increase in
absolute lymphocyte count, increased
phagocytosis, and a rise of serum
bactericidal activity resulted in the
elimination and prevention of the
development of secondary complications
of infections. The author’s conclusion
was that t-activin promoted the
normalization of the thymic structure
and exerted a thymic hormonal
replacement effect not seen in the
control group of 34 SLE children who
received no thymus extract (Kartasheva
91).
Another author used
t-activin to treat SLE in 17 adult
patients. The results showed a
regression of the articular and
cutaneous syndromes as well as a
regression of trophic disorders. The
improvement was attributed to the
functional enhancement of the
neutrophils. Further tests showed an
increased ability to phagocytize killed
Staphylococcus in vitro (Romanov 92).
Scleroderma
Even difficult
diseases such as scleroderma showed
response to thymus extracts used alone (Skotnicki
89, Suchkova 90) or in conjunction with
other drugs (Suchkova 90). The results
of both methods showed a decrease in the
duration, severity and dissemination of
the disease. This was correlated with a
down regulation of the intra-cellular
cAMP/cGMP ratio demonstrating an
association between a functional defect
in the lymphocyte regulatory mechanism
and the disease (Suchkova 90).
Chronic autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
In an unusual study
of 8 patients with warm autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA), TFX thymic
extract was used after the patients had
become refractory to treatment with
glucocorticosteroids, azathioprine and
splenectomies. Treatment with TFX
resulted in 2 patients with
nondetectable levels of antiglobulin.
Five patients showed decreased levels of
antiglobulin on the test, direct
antiglobulin [DAT, aka Coombs test
(Jacobs, p602)]. In addition, eluate
antibody and serum antibody levels were
also decreased as were red blood cell
autoantibodies. No adverse effects of
TFX were noted (Slomkowski 96).
The above studies on
autoimmunity, taken as a whole, present
the interesting possibility that at
least some thymus extracts may be able
to help elevate and possibly normalize
suppressor cell function.
Neoplasms
Cancer is typically
treated with chemotherapy, radiotherapy
and/or surgery. One difficulty with
these treatments is that all three
significantly decrease the ability of
the immune system to adequately
function. Yet an adequately functioning
immune system is essential for any
sustained recovery. Impaired
cell-mediated immunity, in particular,
is involved not only in the growth but
also in the spread of cancer (Berkow 92,
p1288). The following is a summary of
various cancers and their treatment
regimens involving the use of thymus
extracts. In some studies, thymus
extracts were used as an adjunct to
conventional therapy in an effort to
help restore the immune system or
prevent its profound depression and the
immune related complications typically
associated with conventional treatment.
In most instances, thymus extracts
helped restore immune function or
decreased impairment and, in some cases,
appeared to prolong the life of the
patient.
When reviewing the
following studies involving neoplasms,
it should be remembered that new
therapies are typically tried on the
most advanced cases with the poorest
prognoses. Any alteration in the course
of the disease produced by an
experimental therapy is considered to be
a significant event.
Lung Cancer
Cigarette smoking is
associated with over 90% of all lung
tumors. Lung cancers account for 35% of
all cancers in men and 30% in women (Berlow
92, p731). Survival time for over 90% of
these patients is less than 8 months
after diagnosis (Berkow 92, p731).
Thymus extracts have been used singly
and in conjunction with other therapies
in an attempt to stem the rapid progress
of these cancers and to modulate the
deleterious effects of radiotherapy,
chemotherapy and surgery. In addition to
suppressing immunity, chemotherapy also
produces alterations in the terminal
airways even in an unaffected lung, i.e.
chemotherapy causes a significant
impairment of the alveolo-capillary
barrier (the interface between the lung
alveoli and capillaries). Radiotherapy
reduces the total lymphocyte count and T
cell CD4/CD8 ratio in the lungs. The
concomitance of both therapies produces
synergistic effects (Capelli 92) so that
the use of chemotherapy in conjunction
with radiation produces impairment of
the alveolo-capillary barrier, which
compromises oxygen exchange while
simultaneously reducing the total
lymphocyte count. Hence, there is a
reduction of B, T and natural killer
cells along with a reduction in
cytotoxic and suppressor cells; the
major defenses against cancer cells.
Therefore, if competence in
cell-mediated immunity and the related
host survival rate is to be increased,
immunotherapy is necessary just to
overcome the adverse effects of the
anti-cancer therapy given. This is in
addition to re-establishing the already
weakened immune competence evidenced by
the presence of the cancer.
In one study TFX used
alone was administered twice weekly for
10 weeks to 12 patients suffering from
either undifferentiated cell
carcinoma or squamous cell carcinoma.
Subjective and objective clinical
improvements were seen in 10 of the 12
patients. An inhibition of local tumor
growth and decreased metastatic spread
to mediastinal lymph nodes or other
organs was seen. Three patients
experienced a partial regression of
tumor mass. The 6 months survival rate
was increased to 42% in the treated
group compared to 7% in the control
group receiving only symptomatic
treatment (Skotnicki 89).
The effects of
thymostimulin (TP-1) on chemotherapy
induced toxicity and long-term survival
were tested in 26 patients suffering
from small cell lung cancer.
Patients were randomly treated with 6
cycles of alternating chemotherapy
regimens: cyclophosphamide, 4’-epidoxorubicin
and etoposide, alternated with etoposide
and cysplatin. Fifteen of these patients
also received TP-1 (1mg/kg IM) on days
7-14 of each 3-4 week treatment cycle.
At the end of the 6 cycles of
chemotherapy, TP-1 (1mg/kg IM) was given
twice weekly to complete responders
until tumor relapse. Results showed that
there were 7 complete remissions in the
group receiving TP-1 as compared to 1
remission in the control group. Tumor
progression was noted in 4 of the TP-1
group and 7 of the controls. Mean
survival was 14.5 months for the TP-1
treated group and 5.5 months for the
control group. The severity of
neutropenia was significantly lower in
the thymostimulin treated group, however
duration of neutropenia was no
different. There were significantly
fewer chemotherapy induced side effects
in the group receiving TP-1, especially
in the severity and duration of
myelosuppression as well as febrile and
infectious episodes. The authors
reported that treatment with TP-1
resulted in a better quality of life for
patients and an improved ability to
handle chemotherapy at increased doses
and frequency (Macchiarini 89).
Cohen et al
administered thymosin fraction V in
conjunction with other chemotherapy
(including Cyclophosphamide,
Methotrexate and Lomustine) to patients
suffering from small cell lung cancer
for 6 weeks. This was followed by a
regimen of the same chemotherapy in
addition to a varying combination of
vincristine sulfate, doxorubicin
hydrochloride and procarbazine
hydrochloride, and epipodophyllotoxin,
ethylidine glyco-pyranose (VP-16-213)
and ifosfamide for a period of up to 2
years. The group receiving 60 mg/sqn
body area of thymosin fraction V showed
significantly increased survival time
(434 days) compared to controls (263
days). After 1 year of treatment, 33% of
patients receiving thymosin were
disease-free compared to 9% for
controls. The authors reported some
local skin irritation as a mild
localized toxic effect of thymosin which
subsided after 12 to 72 hours (Cohen
79).
The synthetic thymus
extract, thymosin-alpha 1, was used in
conjunction with radio-therapy with non-small
cell lung cancer patients in a
randomized double blind study to
determine whether it could reduce the
immune suppression typically seen in
radiotherapy. Following radiotherapy,
one group (n=15) received twice weekly
injections of thymosin-alpha 1 (900
mcg/m2). The second treatment group
(n=13) received a daily loading dose of
thymosin-alph 1 (900 mcg/m2) for 14 days
followed by injections twice weekly as a
maintenance dose thereafter. A third
group received placebo injections on a
similar schedule. Patients treated with
thymosin using the loading dose schedule
exhibited a normalization of T cell
function by week 11, whereas patients
receiving the twice weekly schedule
exhibited only a partial T cell
restoration which was not sustained over
the 15 weeks of the study. However, the
twice weekly schedule prevented the
gradual decrease in the percentage of T
helper cells seen in both the placebo
and loading dose groups. Overall, the
thymosin-alpha 1 treatment was
associated with significantly reduced
relapses and improved survival time
which was most pronounced in patients
with nonbulky tumors (Scholof 85).
Thymus extracts have
also been shown to significantly reduce
the immunosuppressive effects of
radiotherapy in treating bronchogenic
lung cancer even when the
pretreatment immune responses of the
patient are low (Vuckovic 92).
Radiotherapeutically induced aggravation
of initial immunodeficiency was
prevented by giving the thymic
preparation, Thymex L, to 10 lung cancer
patients simultaneously with
irradiation. A significant decrease of B
and T cell numbers and decreased
lymphocyte proliferative response to PHA
were found in all patients before
radiotherapy. Immediately after
irradiation, proliferation responses
dropped even lower compared to the
pretherapy values. In patients treated
with Thymex L, however, recovery from
radiotherapy produced a significantly
greater number of B and T cells and
greater PHA-induced proliferative
responses than those treated with
radiotherapy only. The authors conclude
that the results indicate Thymex L can
successfully prevent the harmful effects
of radiation therapy on cellular
immunity in a majority of lung cancer
patients.
Another study showed
the effectiveness of thymostimulin in
reducing the chemotoxicity of
chemotherapy on 11 patients with small
cell lung cancer. Patients receiving
chemotherapy in 2 week cycles consisting
of Cyclophosphamide, 4’-Epidoxorubicin,
and Etoposide for 1 week followed by
Cisplatin and Etoposide for the other
week. The cycle was repeated 6 times.
Thymostimulin (1 mg/kg IM) was given on
days 7-14 of every cycle. Responders
received a maintenance treatment
consisting of thymostimulin administered
1 mg/kg IM, twice weekly, until tumor
relapse. Myelosuppression, fever and
documented infectious episodes were
significantly less severe in
thymostimulin treated patients. In
addition, there was significant
improvement in the complete response
rate and survival time of treated
patients (Macchiarini 89).
In another study,
thymostimulin thymus extract, used as
the only therapy in otherwise untreated
lung cancer patients, was able to modify
alveolar lymphocyte numbers and subsets
in cancer patients (Capelli 92).
Primary carcinoma of
the larynx
Ten patients
suffering from primary carcinoma of the
larynx received thymostimulin thymus
extract for 60 days following surgery
for the cancer. One year follow-ups
revealed a significant increase in the
patients’ immune response compared to
controls, but no survival statistics
were given (Mantovani 92).
Carcinomas of the
head and neck
Combined therapy of
carboplatin and radiation was compared
to the same therapy plus the thymus
extract thymostimulin (TP-1) in 36
patients with advanced carcinoma of the
head and neck in a 2 year study. The
thymostimulin treated group showed a
smaller decrease in lymphocyte levels
and a slightly longer disease free
remission interval but had a slightly
higher rate of recurrences and distant
metastases. The overall rate of complete
remissions was the same in both groups
(94%). However, with such high
percentages of complete remissions in
the control group, it would be difficult
to show significant differences in the
treatment group (De Serdio 97).
Patients with head
and neck carcinoma have been shown to
have deficits in cellular immunity (Balm
82, Balm 84, Cameron 84). Thymostimulin
(TP-1) was used 10 days preoperatively
and 6 months post-operatively in 39
patients who underwent surgery for
carcinoma of the head and neck. Another
22 patients with the same disease
underwent surgical removal of the tumor
only. Monocyte and drendritic cell
function was restored in both treated
and untreated groups following surgical
removal of the tumor. However, serum low
molecular mass factors (LMMF) remained
elevated in both groups. The authors
concluded that the similarity of results
in both groups was due to the beneficial
effect of tumor removal on cellular
immunity (Kerrebijn 96).
Immunohistochemical
support for the use of thymus extracts
in the treatment of head and neck
squamous cell carcinoma has also
appeared in the literature.
Thymostimulin (TP-1) was administered
intramuscularly in 3 different dose
levels to randomly assigned groups.
Group 1 (n=4) received placebo
treatment; group 2 was given TP-1 at .5
mg/kg body weight (n=4), group 3 (n=6)
1.0 mg/kg and group 4 (n=8) 2.0 mg/kg
body weight for 10 consecutive days
preoperatively. Histological sections of
the tumor were studied using an image
analysis system (VIDAS RT) to determine
the concentration of T cells,
macrophages, monocytes and dendritic
cells for each tumor. Highly significant
dense T cell infiltration into the
stromal tissue area was seen in tumors
removed from patients in all 3 treatment
groups, i.e. all 3 TS dose levels
produced significant T cell
infiltration. There was also found to be
a positive correlation between tumor T
cell infiltration and dendritic cell
capability to form clusters with T cells
in the peripheral blood. Infiltration of
the other immune cells studied was not
significantly increased. The authors
concluded that pre-operative treatment
of these patients strongly enhanced T
cell infiltration of tumor cells (Kerrebijn
96).
Hodgkin’s disease (lymphogranulomatosis)
Untreated patients
suffering from Hodgkin’s disease
characteristically have defects in
cellular immunity (Martelli 82). In an
attempt to fortify against immune
defects, t-activin, a thymus extract,
was employed in a program involving 366
children afflicted with
lymphogranulomatosis (Hodgkin’s
disease) who also showed other immune
disorders. An increase in immune
parameters and a 5 year survival rate
was obtained in 93.8% of cases (Makhonova
91) compared to 70-80% of cases treated
with radiation and chemotherapy (Berkow
92, p1247).
In another study, 26
children with acute myeloid leukemia
were given t-activin thymus extract
treatment in addition to chemotherapy.
Long term t-activin administration (no
less than 2-3 years) not only reduced
the incidence of intercurent diseases,
but also increased the duration of the
remission period (Drozdova 90). Even in
adult patients with advanced (stages III
and IV) Hodgkin’s disease, the
administration of TFX resulted in an
increased lymphocyte count and increased
T-cell-mediated immunity as evidenced by
DTH skin tests, E-rosettes and PHA
responses. Improvement of hematological
tolerance in patients simultaneously
receiving chemotherapy or radiation
therapy was also seen. This improvement
came even in patients showing lymphocyte
depletion (Marjanska 75, Urban 77).
Another study found similar laboratory
improvements using thymostimulin,
another thymus extract (Martelli 82).
The thymus extract
thymostimulin (TP-1) was used on small
groups of patients in total remission
from Hodgkin’s disease. Subjects were
randomly assigned to 1 of 3 groups.
Group 1 (n=6) received TP-1 daily for 35
days, group 2 (n=6) received TP-1 every
other day for 35 days. Both groups then
received TP-1 twice a week for the
following 22 weeks. Group 3 (n=7) was
not treated. In the group treated daily,
there was a significant increase in all
T-cell fractions after 35 days. The 22
week maintenance therapy did not produce
any further improvement but it did
sustain the increase in T cells as a
percentage and as absolute numbers. The
group receiving therapy every other day
showed increases in T3 and T11 cells
only. Although not statistically
significant, there were indications that
TP-1 might also raise IL-2 and IFN-gamma
levels (Liberati 88).
The administration of
thymus extract to patients suffering
from Hodgkin’s disease and
simultaneous mycobaterial or viral
infections was also found to be "of
important supportive therapeutic
value" (Skotnicki 89).
Non-Hodgkin’s
Lymphoma
Thymostimulin (TP-1)
administered in conjunction with
chemotherapeutic agents was compared to
conventional chemotherapy alone in
patients with intermediate and
high-grade non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
These patients ranged from 13 to 75
years of age and were in clinical stage
II-IV or clinical stage I with bulky
disease and had had no prior treatment.
Of the 134 patients in the study, 68
were randomized to receive chemotherapy
alone and 66 to receive chemotherapy
plus TP-1. TP-1 was administered (1
mg/kg IM) daily on days 22-28 of each 28
day drug cycle to patients treated with
a combination of chemotherapeutic agents
known collectively as Pro-MACE-CytaBOM (prednisone,
methotrexate, adriamycin,
cyclophosphamide, etoposide,
cyclophosphamide, bleomycin, and oncovin
(Vincristine) and on days 22-29, 50-57
and 77-85 to patients treated with the
drug combination MACOP-B (methotrexate,
adriamycin, cyclophosphamide, oncovin,
prednisone and bleomycin). All patients
also received cotrimoxazole (Bactrim™)
and ketoconazole or fuconazole daily.
Results showed that patients treated
with TP-1 plus chemotherapy had a higher
complete remission rate than those
treated with chemotherapy alone (59.1%
vs. 42.6%) and a lower partial remission
rate (21.2% vs. 32.4%). Complete
remission rate was most significant in
patients with intermediate grade
lymphomas, under 60 years of age with
good hemoglobin levels. A 3 year
follow-up showed no statistical
difference in relapse or survival with
29 of the 68 chemotherapy alone group
dead compared to 22 of the 66 in the
TP-1 group. There was also no
statistically significant difference
between the infection rates of the 2
groups. However, the TS group actually
had more infectious episodes (37 vs.
17). There was also no significant
difference in myleotoxicity as assessed
comparing hemoglobin, white blood cell
counts and platelets before and after
treatment. It was not mentioned why TS
was only given for 7 days before and not
during chemotherapy. It was concluded
that patients under 60 who had good
performance scores prior to chemotherapy
and normal bone marrow recovery (30-40%
of all newly diagnosed non-Hodgkin’s
lymphoma patients) may benefit from the
addition of thymic therapy (Federico
95).
To the writer, an
experimental design using such powerful
chemotherapeutic agents—some of the
most cytotoxic agents known for immune
cells—combined with a thymus extract
used only before a round of
chemotherapy, should not be expected to
produce a profound result. The
significant difference in survival of
patients receiving TS is surprising and
encouraging.
Breast cancer
Eighty-five patients
with advanced breast cancer who had
previously undergone mastectomy and were
currently undergoing chemotherapy, were
included in a study dividing patients
into 2 matching groups. One group was
treated with chemotherapy and
thymostimulin while the control ;group
was treated with chemotherapy alone. The
group receiving thymostimulin
experienced approximately1/2 the mild to
severe leukopenia as controls. A
reduction in infections, in addition to
the above results, confirmed the value
of immunotherapy during chemotherapy for
breast cancer (Alba 91). A similar study
using thymostimulin found no significant
statistical differences in immunologic
or haematologic values between those
receiving chemotherapy alone or with
thymostimulin. However, the researchers
observed that administration of the
thymic hormone appeared to protect the
bone marrow and subjects receiving
thymostimulin had a lower incidence of
side effects than the untreated group (Negri
92).
Another study
involving the use of thymus extracts
with breast cancer included 26 women
suffering from breast carcinoma who had
previously undergone mastectomy 1 to 2
years before the study began. Most had
also undergone curettage of the axilla.
Each subject received intramuscular
injections of Thymus Extract Mulli twice
weekly for 4 to 6 weeks. All subjects
were monitored using the
carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) test.
Results showed a reduction of CEA values
in approximately 70% of the cases
treated with thymus extracts compared to
47% for controls. The authors concluded
that because of its effectiveness and
lack of side effects, immunotherapy is
valuable and should be considered as a
therapy in breast cancer (Reinke 85).
Note: The
carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) test is a
test typically used to monitor cancers
of the colon and rectum. It serves as an
index of whether a particular cancer has
spread, is going into remission or is
recurring (Griffith 88). Although it is
used to monitor colorectal cancers, it
also detects breast cancers (Griffith
88, Fischbach 96).
Pavesi (Pavesi 93)
reported a reduction in hematological
toxicity and a favorable effect on
quality of life in approximately 50
women with breast cancer, but no impact
on disease outcome (time to progression
or median survival time) using
thymostimulin (TP-1) given 1 mg/kg body
weight IM daily during chemotherapy and
3 times a week thereafter until
progression or withdrawal from the
study. To see if thymus extracts would
be useful in counteracting the incidence
of infection and myelotoxicity, patients
with early breast cancer were treated
with 6 rounds of a combination of
cyclo-phosphamide, methotrexate and
5-fluorourcil combined with
thymostimulin (TP-1). The patients were
randomly divided into 2 groups with the
treatment group of 25 receiving
chemotherapy plus TP-1 (50 mg/sqm IM)
daily for 2 weeks and subsequently twice
weekly for a minimum of 3 months
compared to a control group of 26
patients receiving the chemotherapy
alone. The results showed the TP-1 group
to have statistically fewer infections
(37% vs 77%), smaller decrease in the
T4/T8 ratio (21% vs 46%), and fewer
delays in chemotherapy protocols because
of myelotoxicity (21% vs 77%). The
authors noted a lower incidence of viral
and fungal infections in the TP-1
treated group. Their conclusion was that
TP-1 seemed useful for reducing the risk
of infection in the early stages of
breast cancer to patients subjected to
chemotherapy and for allowing the
administration of chemotherapy at the
planned intervals without delays caused
by chemo-toxicity (Iaffaioli 88).
Somewhat similar findings were seen in a
group of 27 patients with advanced
breast cancer trated with mitoxantrone
and granulocyte-colony stimulating
factor (G-CSF) plus the thymus extract
thymostimulin (TP-1). G-CSF is an
adjunct used to stimulate neutrophil
production in conjunction with extensive
chemotherapy when there is a high risk
of a neutropenic infection. The results
showed significant differences in
several key haemotological toxicity
indices between the TP-1 treated group
and 27 controls receiving only
chemotherapy. There was a significantly
greater absolute neutrophil count (ANC)
in the TP-1 group than in the controls
as well as significantly fewer days to
upgrade neutropenia to normal in
patients receiving TP-1 (2 vs 10 days
median). The treatment group also
reached acceptable levels of local site
and neutrophil concentrations faster
than controls. Statistically fewer
patients required transfusions of
erythrocytes compared with controls (1
vs 8) and significantly fewer patients
suffered from neutropenic fever (6 vs
16). The incidence (16% vs 59%),
duration (5.5 vs 10 days), and severity
of infection for the treatment group was
also significantly lower than controls.
There was, however, no difference in the
response rate to chemotherapy between
the 2 groups. Thymostimulin was well
tolerated throughout the study (Sanchiz
96).
Colorectal and
gastric cancer
Thymostimulin thymus
extract was used during and after
surgery in 114 cases of gastric and
colorectal cancer. The thymus extract
was shown to be of benefit for
neoplastic patients undergoing surgery
to decrease the surgical stress (Ciconi
92).
In another study 50
patients with inoperable colorectal
cancer received TFX thymus extract
injections over the course of their
disease. The results showed increased
granulocyte and lymphocyte counts with
enhancement of cell mediated immunity,
clinical improvement and increased
survival time. Twelve of the cases had
repeated histological examinations of
the active cancer and surrounding
tissue. The results showed that thymus
therapy produced inflammatory,
granulomatous and fibroblastic reactions
with focal calcification and tumor
necrosis. These changes are comparable
to those seen in spontaneous tumor
regression and are considered to be an
expression of a natural host response to
the invasion of neoplastic tissue (Turowski
76, Urban 77). In situations where the
colorectal cancer is operable, use of
thymus extracts during and after surgery
decreased the surgical stress, thereby
favorably affecting the outcome (Ciconi
92).
Similar results were
also reported in a 15 year review of 457
patients suffering from malignancies of
the gastrointestinal tract and breast
cancer. This study also showed a
reduction in post-operative
complications, better and accelerated
wound healing, and an increased survival
time compared to subjects receiving no
immunotherapy (Cybulski 87).
Mustacchi et al.
explored the possible protective effects
of thymostimulin (TP-1) on chemotherapy
induced leukopenia and related febrile
episodes as well as possible improvement
of therapeutic efficiency and tolerance
when using high dose folinic acid (FA)
and fluorouracil (FU) in metastatic
colorectal cancer. Patients received the
above chemotherapy plus TP-1 given 1
mg/kg of body weight IM per day
concurrent with chemotherapy and 3 times
per week thereafter until tumor
progression, serious toxicity or patient
refusal occurred. Results showed that
the TP-1 treated group had significantly
less gastrointestinal toxicity than
controls. The TP-1 treated group also
showed twice as many complete remissions
(6 vs 3 for controls), more partial
remissions (26 vs 16), fewer days of
treatment due to haemotological toxicity
(46 vs 60 for controls), and fewer
delays due to mucositis and diarrhea (11
vs 22). The author noted the addition of
TP-1 to the fluorofolate combination
improved the response rate without any
significant impact on survival.
Interferon (IFN) added to chemotherapy
has a similar effect on response rate
but does so with extremely heavy
toxicity, which is virtually absent with
this treatment regimen employing TP-1 (Mustacchi
94).
Hepato-cellular
cancer
There is one report
of a small pilot study producing tumor
regression in almost 50% of patients
with hepatocellular cancer treated with
thymostimulin (TP-1) alone. Further
analysis revealed that Kupffer cells
stimulated in vitro by TP-1 released
significant amounts of tumor necrosis
factor-alpha and interleukin 1 alpha
& 6 (Balch 97).
Melanoma
The thymus extract t-activin
was given before surgery and for 6
months following surgery in 8 early
stage melanoma patients. No differences
were seen in the total number of T
cells, T helper, T suppressor, CD38+ and
CD16+ cells. Mitogenic induced
lympho-proliferative responses were also
unaffected. There was a slightly longer,
but statistically insignificant, disease
free period in the t-activin patients
compared to controls who had surgery
alone (17.5 vs 13 months). Although the
above parameters showed no statistically
significant differences, the t-activin
treatment group had an overall survival
time nearly twice that of the control
group (40 vs 23 months). The authors’
explanation was that there were probably
other immune factors involved that were
not measured. Further studies with
larger groups are planned (Garashchenko
96).
Continue...
Due
to the recent problem with the madcow disease,
the FDA has inspected and cleared our Natcell products
for sale.
FDA Clearance No. 110-3122937-2
NO
MADCOW HERE! |
|
|